Third Quarter Collapse: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: Backing the Pack for NC State Fans!


Off-Day Open Thread: Grading the Magic's Draft

So, now that you've had at least one full day to think about the Magic's draft, how would you evaluate it? Did they do well? Could they have done better? Let's take a look.

They Did Well

  1. They got the guy at the top of their draft board without having to trade up.
  2. They got a guy who can contribute immediately; in other words, someone who's on-track with the team's championship aspirations.
  3. They got a guy who gives them depth at one of their weakest positions.

They Did Not-So-Well

  1. They drafted a two-guard, which leaves them with only Tony Battie, Marcin Gortat, and Adonal Foyle (if he re-signs, which seems doubtful at this juncture) to back up Dwight Howard at center.
  2. It also leaves them with no true power forward on their roster.
  3. They couldn't maneuver into the second round; John Denton explains that teams asked for far too much cash than the Magic wanted to offer, which raises the question: why couldn't they have traded into the second round?

Let's take a look around the basketblogosphere and see what it has to say:

  • Kelly Dwyer of Ball Don't Lie did not like the Magic's decision to select Lee. In his team-by-team rundown of draft picks, Dwyer gave the Magic a 3 out of 10, the second-lowest score for any team he rated (Dallas got a 0, and several teams didn't make moves and were thus not evaluated). Why is Dwyer down on Orlando's decision?
    The guy is going to be 23 on opening night, and couldn't even put together huge numbers for a so-so Western Kentucky team. I am not a fan. If you disagree, bookmark this and talk to me in three years.
  • For his part, ESPN's Chad Ford wasn't impressed with the Magic's pick either, rating their draft as a B-. Ford mentions the Magic would have been better served drafting Darrell Arthur, then writes, "I'm not down on Lee, but he's not a guy who can put them over the top." Hardly anyone gets an over-the-top kind of player at 22, so I think Ford might have overreacted a bit with this grade.
  • Marty Burns of Sports Illustrated goes a bit lighter on the Magic, rating their draft a B. His justification? Lee was the best available two-guard left when they picked. I'm sure Magic fans in the Chris Douglas-Roberts camp will have something to say about that, as Douglas-Roberts slipped (!) all the way to the Nets with the 40th (!!) overall pick.
  • Sam Smith of the Sporting News likes the Magic's pick because he thinks it means the end of the J.J. Redick "era" -- his word, not mine. Smith gave the team a B.
  • Mike DeCourcy, also of the Sporting News, didn't hand out grades, but did say that Lee is "a better athlete than any guard in this draft, save for Russell Westbrook." He calls Lee "a solid choice" at 22 for Orlando. And, like Smith, he thinks J.J.'s as good as gone. (Sporting News links via BrewHoop)
  • UPDATE: Jonathan Givony of DraftExpress gives the Magic a B, which on his scale means they "did well in filling their needs, getting fair value from their pick and getting a prospect that fits their system in the direction the franchise is heading in," according to the scale at the beginning of the article.

Me? I was all set to give the Magic a B+, but their failure to get into the second round of the draft, and thus their lack of depth at power forward, made me grade them a B-. If they have to go through another season with Rashard Lewis at power forward (read: getting killed on their offensive boards) because they thought $200,000 was too much to pay for the right to draft a rebounder, none of us will be pleased. And if Arthur blooms into an All-Star, well, crap.

But what say you, 3QC readers? How'd the Magic do? Vote in the poll and add your thoughts in the comments.

Poll
Give Otis and Dave a grade for their work (or, "non-work," a cynical Magic fan might say) on draft night.
A - Lee is what they need.
5 votes
B - Lee will work out okay, but I'm ticked they didn't get into the second round.
28 votes
C - Getting a two-guard is nice and all, but there were better fits for Orlando still available.
22 votes
D - I have visions of Reece Gaines and Jeryl Sasser.
6 votes
F - At least Fran Vazquez is a power forward.
7 votes

68 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs | Comment 5 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

It seems to me that the Magic were still at least contemplating paying up for a 2nd rounder. I think Portland knew that a few teams were hot for Dorsey. Them turning around and trading him right after further proves the point to me..

by coque429 on Jun 28, 2008 12:16 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Denton mentions that the Magic gave up once D.J. White and Joey Dorsey went off the board. I think the question a lot of us should ask is “Why?”

by Ben Q Rock on Jun 28, 2008 4:16 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Because they’re not very good at their jobs?

by eltharion_doa on Jun 29, 2008 12:31 AM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

I give them a C for passing on Arthur and Koufas. Picking up an additional 1st or a 2cd would have been solid, especially since CDR could have been had for cheap. I really like Lee now after watching some video on him so I am actually glad they made that pick, but why not grab another first and draft Arthur or Koufas? Lack of imagination or balls or something keeps Otis from being a great GM.

'Coach, Dwight is a nice guy. Dwight don't hit anybody. But Superman will knock the crap out of you.' - D12

by Eyriq the Red on Jun 28, 2008 3:30 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Another first-rounder might have cost them an actual player, and with J.J.’s value plummeting, there wasn’t a real trade to be had. But we should have been more active/aggressive in getting into the second round of the draft.

by Ben Q Rock on Jun 28, 2008 4:18 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Celebrating 20 years of Orlando Magic basketball


Community Guidelines


Vince Carter Presser Transcript

Start posting about the Magic »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Brandon Bass: what's the attraction?

Recent FanPosts

Nba_small
Vince Carter or Hedo Turkoglu? No question indeed.
47715577_small
Hedo Turkoglu's Market Shake-Up
Img_0303__2__small
Anybody else thinking there's more homeless talent than money right now?
Nba_small
The Rasheed Wallace effect: Part Orlando
Maxav_small
Ariza to Rockets
Small
Hey Otis...Sign Linas Kleiza
Hedotugthejersey_small
Ron Artest to LAKERS?!?!?!
Hedotugthejersey_small
So Let's Assume . . .
200px-astoncolossus_small
Rudy Fernandez in a Magic Uniform?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

Tiny Blogroll

Rather than include our complete blogroll in this space, we've decided to link to it instead. That way, you won't have to do as much scrolling. Enjoy.


Managing Editor

3qcrockjersey_small Ben Q Rock

Contributing Editor

Orlando-lee-306_small erivera7

Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports